Monitoring the participation of status holders: what to measure and how

A Dutch municipality monitors the social participation of status holders on three levels: participation hours and progress per newcomer, activities per provider and outcomes per municipality. Registration happens only on the first level, in a digital system that records hours per person.
The other two levels use that registration plus the national figures from Statistics Netherlands (CBS) and Divosa. Most answers to this question miss that distinction. Anyone searching for tools to monitor participation finds civic-participation platforms, research monitors and self-reliance questionnaires side by side. Below is what the Wet inburgering 2021 (Civic Integration Act) asks of a municipality, what separates monitoring from registration, and a comparison of four kinds of tools.
What the Civic Integration Act asks of the municipality
Since the Wet inburgering 2021, the municipality is responsible for the broad intake, the personal integration and participation plan (PIP), monitoring the progress of the integration, and the offer of the labor market and participation module (MAP), the participation statement track (PVT) and the learning route. Divosa, the association of municipal directors in the social domain, lists these tasks in its overview of the Act (in Dutch). Monitoring is a statutory task of the municipality, not an extra service.
The heaviest part sits in the Z-route, the self-reliance route. According to DUO, the Dutch executive agency for civic integration, it consists of at least 800 hours of language lessons and at least 800 hours of participation, including the PVT and the MAP, plus a final interview with the municipality. In its guide on participation in civic integration, Divosa writes that municipalities are obliged to keep an accurate record of the participation hours in the Z-route and report them to DUO. The B1-route and the education route carry no national hour norm for participation; the municipality sets the expectation per person in the PIP.
Monitoring and registration are two different tasks
Registration records facts: which status holder was at which activity, when, with which provider, for how many hours. Monitoring checks whether those facts match the plan and whether the policy works. A municipality that only registers has a timesheet; a municipality that only monitors has an annual report without figures per person. You need both, and they play on three levels.
Level 1: per newcomer
The question here is whether this person is on track against the PIP: hours done, hours approved, hours still needed. Divosa advises giving newcomers insight into their own hours and progress and planning a monthly contact moment to discuss obstacles. This is the level where registration happens and where a case manager steers.
Level 2: per provider and activity
Which providers deliver hours, which activities get canceled, where do newcomers stop showing up. This level comes directly out of the level 1 registration, provided every provider works in the same system. If half of them work through email and a spreadsheet, you see this level only afterwards.
Level 3: per municipality
Here you compare your own outcomes with those of other municipalities: how many newcomers complete the route, how many find work, how the municipality compares with its region. National sources exist for this that you do not have to build yourself: the Civic Integration Act statistics dashboard of Statistics Netherlands (CBS), the Divosa Benchmark Status Holders & Civic Integration, in which municipalities compare their figures with more than 180 other municipalities, and the annual KIS monitor of municipal policy, which KIS runs together with Divosa. These sources say something about policy per year, nothing about one newcomer this week.
Comparing four kinds of tools for monitoring participation
A registration system for participation hours is the only one of the four kinds that records hours per newcomer itself; the other three measure something else or were built for another audience. The table puts them side by side.
| Criterion | Measurement instrument (e.g. self-reliance matrix) | Policy monitor or benchmark (CBS, Divosa, KIS) | Registration system for participation hours | Civic-participation platform |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What it measures | Self-reliance per life domain, at a few moments in the track | Outcomes per municipality and region, per year or quarter | Hours, attendance and activity per newcomer, per day | Residents' opinions and initiatives on policy |
| Level | 1 (per person, qualitative) | 3 (municipality) | 1 and 2 (person and provider) | None of the three |
| Delivers the hours for DUO | No | No | Yes, that is its purpose | No |
| Who fills it in | Case manager, in conversation | CBS and the benchmark partners, from national registers | Newcomer and provider, approved by the municipality | Residents |
| Personal data | Yes, sensitive: a report per person | No, aggregated | Yes: name, hours, activity; the citizen service number stays with the municipality | Usually not |
| Sufficient as the only tool | No, says nothing about hours | No, says nothing about persons | No, says nothing about self-reliance or policy | No, wrong audience |
A measurement instrument such as the Zelfredzaamheid-Matrix (self-reliance matrix, described by Movisie in Dutch) maps how self-reliant someone is per life domain, at intake, midway and at the end. That is valuable next to the hour registration, not instead of it. A civic-participation platform drops out: it was built to let residents have a say in policy, not to follow the participation of status holders, even though it shows up in search results on the same term.
How to set it up: five steps
- Record the norm per newcomer in the PIP. In the Z-route that is at least 800 hours of participation; in the B1-route and the education route you set it yourself. Without a norm per person you cannot monitor, only count.
- Choose one registration system that every provider works in. Divosa advises a user-friendly digital system that gives the newcomer insight into their own hours; it reduces manual errors and makes level 2 visible without phone calls.
- Settle the GDPR side before the first provider logs in. Providers of the MAP, the PVT and the social guidance carry out a municipal task and are processors, so you sign a data processing agreement with each of them; other local providers may not use the newcomer's citizen service number (BSN). Divosa explains this in its privacy questions on the Act (in Dutch), with a pointer to the standard processing agreement and the DPIA of the Association of Dutch Municipalities (VNG). How to set that up in practice is in Monitoring participation hours of status holders: transparent and GDPR-proof.
- Discuss progress with the newcomer every month. Show the hours, name what is still needed and ask why activities did not happen. The registration is the material for the conversation; the conversation is the monitoring.
- Put your own figures next to the national ones every quarter. Completed routes, dropout and work are in the CBS dashboard and the Divosa benchmark; the delivery to DUO and CBS is explained in Reporting participation hours to the Dutch government. Which indicators to add yourself is in Which indicators belong in a municipal integration dashboard.
Where Taaly fits
Taaly is the registration system in the table, built for levels 1 and 2: the status holder registers participation hours with a QR code at the activity, the municipality and its chain partners see the hours in real time instead of in a report afterwards, and the municipality (or the organization it designates) approves the hours. A missed QR check-in is added by the newcomer in the app or by the case manager in the Taaly dashboard. 12 municipalities register hours via Taaly; the first municipal pilot of the hour-registration module resulted in 80% less administration.
Level 3 is not in Taaly: CBS and Divosa are the source there. Taaly's results are, however, externally validated with the OpenEmbassy Integratie Impact Framework, so a municipality can put the outcomes of the activities in Taaly Meedoen next to its own policy figures. How the hour registration works is on the participation hours page.
Want to see what the registration and the dashboard look like for your municipality? Request a demo.
Frequently asked questions
How can municipalities effectively monitor and register the social participation of status holders?
By separating registration from monitoring. You register per newcomer in one digital system that every provider works in, with the hours set against the norm in the PIP. You monitor on three levels: monthly per newcomer in a progress conversation, continuously per provider from the same registration, and per quarter or year at municipal level with the CBS Civic Integration Act dashboard and the Divosa benchmark.
Which tools exist to monitor the social participation of newcomers?
Four kinds: measurement instruments such as the self-reliance matrix (self-reliance per life domain), policy monitors and benchmarks from CBS, Divosa and KIS (outcomes per municipality), registration systems for participation hours such as Taaly (hours per newcomer, approved by the municipality) and civic-participation platforms (residents having a say in policy). Only a registration system delivers the hours a municipality reports to DUO in the Z-route.
Is a civic-participation tool suitable for following the participation of status holders?
No. Civic-participation tools are built to inform, consult or let residents co-decide on policy. They do not register hours per person and do not know the norm from the PIP. They appear on the same search term because of the word participation, not because of what they do.
How many participation hours does a status holder have to complete?
In the Z-route at least 800 hours of participation, including the participation statement track and the labor market and participation module, next to at least 800 hours of language lessons (DUO). The B1-route and the education route have no national hour norm; the municipality sets the expectation per person in the PIP.
How do you monitor participation hours in a GDPR-proof way?
Sign a data processing agreement with every provider of the MAP, the PVT and the social guidance, do not share the citizen service number with other local providers, use the standard processing agreement and the DPIA of the VNG, and choose a system in which the municipality approves the hours. Divosa answers the privacy questions on the Wet inburgering 2021 on its site; the step-by-step setup is in our article on GDPR-proof monitoring.